The Forge
The Forge - Catholic Commentary
New Briefs #5
0:00
-3:24

New Briefs #5

Just War, Assisted Dying, and What the Church Is Actually Saying

New York Bishops Issue End-of-Life Guide as Assisted Suicide Law Takes Effect This Summer

Following Governor Kathy Hochul’s signing of the Medical Aid in Dying Act in February, New York’s bishops released an updated pastoral guide titled “Now and at the Hour of Our Death” — an eight-page pamphlet explaining Catholic moral principles around end-of-life care, set to become newly relevant when the law takes effect in August 2026. What makes this worth reading isn’t just the opposition to assisted suicide — the guide does something more useful. It walks through the Church’s distinction between ordinary care (which is morally obligatory, including nutrition and hydration) and extraordinary care (which is morally optional), and encourages Catholics to designate a healthcare proxy who will honor their faith-based values. This is practical formation, not just a protest document. If you have aging parents or are thinking through your own advance directives, this is worth tracking down.

Barr Says Iran War Meets Just War Criteria — Pope and U.S. Bishops Push Back

At a NAPA Institute panel, former Attorney General Bill Barr argued that U.S. military action against Iran does not clearly violate just war doctrine, citing Iran's potential nuclear capability as a legitimate threat. His comments come as Pope Leo XIV has been increasingly outspoken against the war — calling the threat against the Iranian people "truly unacceptable," urging political leaders to return to the negotiating table, and stating that "God does not bless any conflict." The Pope has stopped short of a formal just war ruling, but his moral language has been pointed and consistent. Several U.S. cardinals and Vatican officials have gone further in questioning whether the war meets just war criteria. The debate playing out in Catholic circles is a real one — and Barr's invocation of Augustine and just war reasoning at a Catholic forum makes it worth following closely.

A Consecrated Host Found Intact After 47 Days in a Bombed Lebanese Church

A Melkite priest returning to the town of Tbenine in southern Lebanon following the ceasefire found a consecrated host intact after 47 days in his damaged church, saying that “Jesus was waiting for us.” This story isn’t making many headlines, but it’s getting quiet attention in Catholic circles. Whether one treats it as a miracle or simply as a remarkable fact, it carries weight — a small sign of presence amid destruction. Worth knowing about.

The World’s Oldest Nun Turns 113: “My Whole Mind Is on God”

Sister Francis Piscatella, the world’s oldest nun, recently turned 113. Born in 1913, she joined the Dominicans at 17 and spent her life as a teacher. When asked the secret to her longevity, she said simply, “My whole mind is on God.” In an era saturated with wellness content and longevity obsession, there’s something almost jarring about that answer in its simplicity. It’s not a program or a discipline — it’s an orientation. The contrast is worth sitting with.

Catholic Scholars Wrestle With What Just War Demands After a War Has Already Begun

America Magazine convened a group of Catholic scholars to address a harder version of the just war question: not just whether the Iran war was justified at the outset, but what moral obligations the United States carries now that damage has already been done — and whether an initial violation of just war principles affects those duties going forward. This is the kind of applied Catholic moral reasoning that rarely gets public attention. Most people only encounter just war theory as a yes-or-no question about whether to go to war. This conversation pushes further — into the territory of jus post bellum, the morality of how a conflict is concluded. Worth following.

The SPLC Was Just Indicted for Fraud — and the Story Is Complicated

The Southern Poverty Law Center was indicted on federal fraud charges in April, with the Justice Department alleging it secretly funneled more than $3 million in donor funds to paid informants inside the Ku Klux Klan and other extremist groups — without disclosing this to donors. The case has split people predictably along political lines, but the underneath question is genuinely interesting: SPLC attorneys have argued that their informant program shared intelligence with the FBI and helped put violent extremists in prison, while prosecutors claim that some informants continued engaging in extremist activity while being paid by the SPLC. For Catholics — especially those who have been labeled by the SPLC as a “hate group” for holding orthodox positions on marriage and sexuality — this story carries a particular weight. Whether the indictment is a legitimate prosecution or political targeting is worth watching closely as the case develops

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?